LTE: When Public Input Is Paid For, Collected, And Then Set Aside|

BY KEVIN HOLSAPPLE
Los Alamos

When Los Alamos County spends public money to ask residents where they stand on major community choices, the public reasonably expects their answers to matter. Yet in the Comprehensive Plan update process, the County paid for a dedicated survey to gauge community views on key issues and alternatives, drew roughly 250+ responses, and then disregarded the results when drafting the update. The Planning & Zoning Commission Chair, David Hampton, told me those inputs were “bad data”—and so were ignoed. Instead, the draft includes alternatives that were minority preferences in the survey results.

Nobody suggests that the County open-participation survey is a weighted scientific poll. However, that does not excuse what happened next. The P&Z largely rubber-stamped an unclear plan, not grounded in public input, to send to the Council for final approval. The whole farce exposes a basic contradiction in how the County designs, uses, and explains public engagement—and it offers another strong example of why community trust in local government has fallen so sharply and is so dismal. Despite plenty of survey and qualitative feedback from residents, the county ignored the community preferences when drafting the updated plan and didn’t explain why it supported minority community preferences.

Look at the County’s own fresh 2026 National Community Survey results, which are based on a scientific, demographically weighted probability sample. The steepest declines cluster directly around governance, public participation, and institutional credibility:

  • Overall confidence in Los Alamos County government plunged 13 percentage points to 33%, ranking near the bottom nationally among more than 300+ benchmarked communities.
  • Being open and transparent to the public fell 11 points to 36%, also near the bottom.
  • Welcoming resident involvement dropped 10 points to 36%, also near the bottom.
  • Value of services for the taxes paid fell 13 points to 47%, marking the first time in the survey’s history that fewer than half of residents perceive they are getting their tax money’s worth.

Those numbers do not happen in a vacuum. Citizens form their view of local government by watching how it handles their input when decisions are on the line. When the county commissions a survey on Comprehensive Plan alternatives, invites residents to weigh in, and then waves away the outcome once the answers point away from their preferred options, people draw an obvious conclusion: participation is welcome only when it confirms a predetermined direction.

To restore credibility—and ensure public outreach is more than a futile, performative box-checking exercise—when considering final approval, councilors should answer these straightforward questions on the public record:

  1. Why choose an open participation survey format if statistical significance was required? If a probability sample was necessary to inform choices among Comprehensive Plan alternatives, why did the county spend time and public funds on an open-participation survey designed to collect self-selected responses rather than scientific polling—and what role was that survey ever intended to play?
  2. What justified selecting minority-preferred options? Given that the 250+ respondents favored alternatives different from those written into the draft, what concrete evidence, technical constraints, or broader community data outweighed what participants indicated as preferences?
  3. How does the county treat non-random input when it conflicts with staff preferences? Decision-makers routinely cite emails, meeting testimony, and open feedback when they align with a favored decision. Staff is given extensive time at public meetings to sell their preferences. What is the County’s standard for giving equal consideration to and weighing open-participation survey input and other community input when they disagree?
  4. What consideration will be given to the citizen petition? The P&Z ignored a citizen petition (87 signers by the time of the meeting) asking for specific changes/verifications to the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) in the draft plan and the inclusion of a policy request to set a higher standard for rezoning Open Space parcels. Signatures will continue to be collected for the petition to be presented again to the council when the draft is considered for approval.

Open-participation survey results are not “bad data,” as the P&Z chairperson suggested; they are structured public feedback that deserves honest labeling and a clear explanation when the county chooses another path. Until Los Alamos County and its councils, boards, and commissions value public input and explain to the community how it is represented in matters requiring approval (or why it was ignored), dismal confidence in local government should surprise no one.