LTE: Why The November 10 Comprehensive Plan Update Draft Is Not Ready For Prime Time

BY KEVIN HOLSAPPLE
Los Alamos

When Los Alamos County planners released the Revised Draft of PLAN Los Alamos on November 10, 2026, initial headlines highlighted several welcome adjustments. Following a surge of public feedback on the August initial review draft, county planners completely removed the oxymoronic “Conservation Residential” policy overlay, stripped out some objectionable phrasing, and expanded Future Land Use Map guidelines to support accessory dwelling units and missing-middle housing choices.

While these modifications represent improvement, a rigorous evaluation of the November 10 draft against community survey data and public engagement records reveals a troubling reality: the revisions are largely cosmetic. Beneath the softened language and removed overlays, the plan’s core framework remains fundamentally unchanged despite the public input gathered and submitted. The draft still contains policy statements and creates loopholes that give the county rationale to do whatever it wants.

Worse still, staff has presented the Planning and Zoning (P&Z) Commission with a false binary on their meeting agenda—offering only two options: “approve” or “approve with conditions.” Commissioners must reject this trap. Where are the options “reject” and “send back to drafters to get problems corrected”? The November 10 draft contains fatal visual, legal, and policy flaws, and the only responsible action is to send it back for further work.

1. Visual Confusion: The Land Use Map Legend Defect

A comprehensive plan’s most critical implementation tool is its Future Land Use Map (FLUM). Yet the map published in the November 10 draft contains severe visual ambiguities that make it impossible for citizens or commissioners to determine the county’s true land-use intent.

First, the November 10 FLUM completely omits property parcel lines, obscuring where recommended zoning designation boundaries actually lie. Second, and most egregiously, the map legend uses shades of green for both “Active Open Space” and “Passive Open Space” that do not match the shades of green in the map legend.

When a land use map uses mismatched colors, omits parcel lines, and fails to clearly distinguish recommended uses for parcels, it is not a working policy map—it seems more like an exercise in obfuscation. Citizens cannot verify which open space parcels are protected and which remain exposed to development.

2. Legal Loopholes & The Exploitation of Open Space

Beyond visual defects, the November 10 draft slips in permissive, loophole-ridden language into open space zoning definitions. In describing the passive and active open space categories, the draft inserts evasive modifiers such as “generally,” “predominantly,” and “primarily,” and adds the phrase “Residential and commercial development is generally discouraged.”

Stating that residential development is “generally discouraged” in open space is a wide-open administrative backdoor. Residential and commercial development has no place in parcels designated as open space. The definitions should explicitly state that residential and commercial uses are prohibited in open space zoned parcels, not merely “discouraged.”

This ambiguity feeds directly into a persistent community concern regarding “Active Open Space” (OS-AO). Residents who pay attention widely view OS-AO as an ambiguous zoning category that leaves OS-AO-zoned lands vulnerable to high-impact municipal projects. Under the current administration, the Parks and Recreation Department seems to interpret OS-AO to mean that any project they label as “recreation” is fine in OS-AO—horse stables, rodeo grounds, developed bike parks, RV parks, parking lots, RV storage, buildings, gazebos, and more are all permitted on OS-AO-zoned land. Without strict definitions prohibiting commercial and residential uses, OS-AO remains a gateway for municipal sprawl.

3. Defensive Retreat Without Proactive Parcel Protection

Removing the “Conservation Residential” category in November was necessary, but removing a threat is not the same as securing protection. While the drafters stopped proposing housing overlays on open spaces, the November 10 draft completely ignored proactive, parcel-level rezoning requests submitted by citizens based on county Open Space Working Group (OSWG) recommendations.

To restore community trust and permanently protect natural assets, citizens have identified specific county Tax Parcel Identification Numbers (PINs) that must be formally reclassified and retained as Passive Open Space (OS-PO) on the county’s FLUM and Land Use Map:

  • NM 502 Entry Gateway Corridor & Canyon Rim Buffer: Protect the primary entrance to the Los Alamos townsite between Canyon Rim Trail and Main Hill Road from commercial or industrial encroachment (PINs: 1035112415245, 1036112150197, 1035112396224, 1035112091320, 1034112485320, 1034112471301).
  • Lower Bayo Canyon: Fulfill municipal promises made during the Golf Course compromise—supported by the Golf Association—to permanently secure lower canyon lands (PIN: 1036113098289).
  • Golf Course Forested Tracts: Protect critical forest buffers and wildlife corridors surrounding and immediately south of the golf course (PINs: 1033113369371, 1034113053434, 1033113053422).
  • Orange Street Drainage Parcel: Secure vital watershed filtration and local drainage corridors ( PIN: 1033113478047 ).
  • White Rock Canyon Rim & Connecting Open Space: Preserve canyon rim vistas and contiguous open space tracts in White Rock (PINs: 10401082704320002, 10401082704320001, 1038108414200, 1039108428175, 1039108129222).
  • Piñon Park Undeveloped Area: Restore open space zoning to undeveloped parkland incorrectly mis-zoned to White Rock Town Center (PIN: 1039108030436).

Furthermore, most OSWG survey respondents (input submitted to drafters in response to the prior draft) support a binding policy that would make it “very difficult” for local government to rezone designated passive open space for other uses in the future. The November 10 draft failed to clearly designate these parcel rezonings or establish heightened legal barriers, leaving natural lands vulnerable to administrative reclassification.

4. The Growth Fallacy: Ignoring the Community Majority Input

A central tension in the planning process revolves around population growth expectations. In the March 2026 official county online survey (the one that was done to inform this comp plan update), a clear majority of respondents—53.45 percent—explicitly stated, “We should plan for a stable population. We should aim to be a thriving and sustainable county of 20,000 residents—achieving our goals without a larger population.” Only 38.28 percent favored proactive population growth.

In the November 10 draft, there is no use of this input, and the drafters removed specific numeric population projection figures from the main growth diagram. But while the numbers were erased from the graphic, the plan’s underlying growth philosophy remained intact.

The November 10 draft retains an aggressive municipal posture that commits public intervention, Metropolitan Redevelopment Area (MRA) funding, tax incentives, and public financial risk to accommodate ongoing job expansion at Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL). Rather than planning for long-term population stability and municipal sustainability, as most citizens requested, the draft continues to frame municipal capital spending as a vehicle to absorb lab-driven regional growth.

5. The “Affordable Housing” Muddle: Abandoning Essential Workforce Housing

No issue illustrates the gap between public input and draft policies more starkly than housing affordability. Survey data shows that 78 percent of residents rate housing as a top priority for economic vitality, but only 7 percent rate the availability of affordable, quality housing positively.

Resident input emphasized that public housing support policy must target essential service workers—daycare providers, teachers, medical technicians, retail clerks, and school support staff—earning $15 to $20 per hour ($31,200 to $41,600 annually). Because high Laboratory salaries push the county’s median household income above $100,000+, the standard federal Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Area Median Income (AMI) threshold for what is “affordable” doesn’t apply to our most important housing problem. Our county needs policy to set a lower income threshold for investment in affordable housing projects.

Despite clear public input supporting this policy recommendation, the November 10 draft ignored it without explanation.

6. Real Estate Master Planning vs. Local Business Support

While 77 percent of residents rate local business support as a high priority, commercial vitality metrics remain dismal: only 14 percent rate the variety of local businesses positively, and downtown vibrancy sits at just 20 percent.

In September 2025, the Los Alamos Local Business Coalition submitted a comprehensive report and “Idea Book” based on broad merchant outreach. Local business owners identified the primary obstacle to economic vitality as an overly restrictive, cautious county bureaucracy prioritizing risk avoidance over opportunity. The Coalition recommended concrete mechanisms to address commercial blight and downtown stagnation. These inputs were also given as input to this comp plan update process.

The November 10 draft ignored this input without explanation. Instead of listening to local businesses, the draft relies on traditional real estate master planning and proposes expanding the East Downtown Metropolitan Redevelopment Area (MRA) westward to 19th/20th Streets, omitting an important Creative District and downtown property further west (SALA). Continuing to offer subsidies and tax incentives to real estate developers while ignoring recommendations from local businesses will not solve downtown commercial decay.

7. The “Strategic Framework for Implementation” (Part 3) Disregards Public Input and Preferences

When analyzing how the community views the draft plan proposes “Active / Development-Focused Approach”, survey data and qualitative feedback reveal a clear pattern: residents strongly object to giving county staff broad latitude to take on financial risk and grant developer subsidies without binding public returns. , They strongly support focused municipal action when it is directed at specific community priorities.

The analysis from the community survey specifically conducted to find out community preferences shows that 64.14% objected to the active approach without guardrails (26.3% ‘Absolutely Not’ and 16.7% ‘Probably Not’ and 21.1% stated ‘It Depends’) A plurality rejected the active approach. Only 32.7% supported it (23.5% ‘Absolutely’ and 9.2% ‘Probably, Yes’). How in any world did the draft adopt the “Active / Development-Focused Approach”? The draft plan grants county staff broad latitude for developer incentives and public financial risk and completely omits any of the guardrails discussed in qualitative public input.

Conclusion: Send the Draft Back for Alignment With Community Input

Public engagement must not be reduced to a performative exercise in which public input and survey data are collected and then sidelined during policy drafting. The November 10 revision showed that public input can drive necessary corrections—such as eliminating the “Conservation Residential” category. But stopping there leaves Los Alamos with a Comprehensive Plan plagued by visual defects, legal loopholes, and unaddressed community preferences, requests, and concerns.

The Planning and Zoning Commission should reject the staff’s narrowly defined choice between approval and approval with conditions. The Commission should vote to  send the November 10 draft back for further revisions, instructing planners to:

  • Fix Map Ambiguities & Eliminate Loopholes: Draw clear parcel lines on the FLUM, resolve map legend color mismatches, and replace permissive phrasing (“generally discouraged”) with explicit prohibitions on commercial and residential development in open space.
  • Revise the Draft Plan to Enact Proactive Open Space Protections: Recommend verification or formal rezoning of Lower Bayo Canyon, the forested tracts around the golf course, the NM 502 gateway corridor, the Orange Street parcel, Piñon Park, and White Rock rim parcels to Passive Open Space (OS-PO) using specific parcel PINs provided, and establish heightened legal requirements for open space rezoning.
  • Revise the draft plan to establish policy targeting housing subsidies to essential workforce housing: Replace lab-inflated HUD AMI definitions with a dedicated $15–$20/hour housing policy (the policy will continue to fall within the Federal guideline).
  • Realign Growth & Business Policies: Respect the majority preference for population stability (~20,000 residents), and consider Local Business Coalition recommendations.
  • Strategic Framework for Implementation (Part 3): Based on the input given to the plan update process, a strategy that would correspond to community input is a “Community-Accountable Approach,” NOT an “Active/Development-Focused Approach”! A “Community-Accountable Approach” supports targeted investments in community priorities like essential workforce housing and local business support, rather than broad, speculative growth. Targeted investments need guardrails to ensure they deliver community benefits. At the same time, the “Community-Accountable Approach” recognizes the community’s strong desire to retain key community assets, such as lands designated with open space zoning. Part 3 needs to be rewritten to support a “Community-Accountable Approach” that does not support giving carte blanche to the county staff.
  • Hold a Public Workshop if Needed: If drafters or P&Z do not understand the public inputs, why not hold a public workshop that would allow for two-way explanation and dialogue? Any hurry is being artificially imposed on the P&Z.